The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIV, No. 4 · November 1920
135printed page
scan 35 of 44

The Maccabaean

tion to the Jewish people, that makes more painful the fact that in his last moment he remained indifferent to the higher aspirations of his people.

The Zionist Organization of America adopted the following resolution on Mr. Schiff:

The Zionist Organization of America deeply mourns the loss of that great, noble American Jew, Jacob H. Schiff. His patriotic, public-spirited services, his benefactions to the spread of education, his promotion of international good-will, his loyalty to his people and his faith, his untiring solicitude for the unending sorrow and tragedy of the Jewry of Eastern Europe, his constant sympathy for the poor and needy until his name became synonymous with world-wide benevolence—these have made him one of the outstanding figures in modern Jewish history. With unageing mind and undrooping spirit he came in the last years of his life to sympathize and support the Palestine Restoration. The problem of our people thrown into still sharper relief by the events of the war brought about his courageous change of attitude—a change that found expression in his public declaration: “The time has come when the American Jew who has accomplished so much will be united in helping with his means, with his intelligence, with his prestige, the Jewish Homeland in Palestine.”

He has left a heritage of self-forgetting and devoted service to Israel's life and hopes.

The Problem of Palestine

The problems confronting Sir Herbert Samuel, as High Commissioner of Palestine, are discussed in an article in the Fortnightly Review of London, by a former judicial officer in Palestine. The writer, stating that “the Jewish nationality is already installed as such in the country itself,” proceeds to discuss the status of the other nationality in Palestine, the Arabs, and the attitude of the latter to the British policy with regard to a Jewish Palestine. Is the Arab opposition serious and genuine, or is it artificially cultivated by political and religious propaganda? The writer seeks to answer these questions.

Of the Arab population of 600,000, the majority are fellaheen, or peasants cultivating land either actually their own or leased from the big landowners and effendis. Now, these peasants, or fellaheen, are natives in the sociological sense of possessing a barbaric and sub-European culture and mentality. For the most part the fellaheen are illiterate. Ask the fellah, for instance, if he can read or write, and he will express the widest surprise at so preposterous a question. If left to himself, he has no political consciousness and no political aspirations, asking nothing better than to be left in peace to cultivate his own plot of ground, and to indulge in the national sport of village intrigue and the bringing of false charges against his neighbor. Though vindictive, he is by temperament pacific rather than aggressive. His relations with the Jews have usually been harmonious. He has benefited by contact with people pursuing a modern and European culture, and his standard of life has frequently been ameliorated in consequence.

On the other hand, his mentality is that of a baby. He will lie or steal with the healthy, natural simplicity of a child, and, when detected, own up without shame with the same matter-of-fact simplicity. He has little sense of ethics as such, but in its stead an acutely developed religious fanaticism and superstition.

Needless to say, he is extraordinarily susceptible to influence and propaganda. Socially, economically, and politically, moreover, he lives in subjection to the Sheikhs and effendis, who have exercised, and are endeavoring to exercise, an essentially feudal domination.

It is, then, from the effendi class that there sprang the most violent opposition to the Zionist policy of his Majesty's Foreign Office, as embodied in the Balfour Declaration and the San Remo Conference.

The Jewish population of Palestine form a distinct contrast to the Arabs.

If the Arabs are illiterate and corrupt, the Jews are, if anything, over-intellectualized and ultra-idealistic. It is unnecessary to pump into them that consciousness of their nationality which is bubbling and gushing forth at all times and in all places. Having left Europe for Palestine in order to lead a national Jewish life, a national Jewish life is the inspiration and impetus, not to say the obsession, of every single hour. The new Hebrew culture, though essentially and aggressively nationalistic, is European, and the new Hebrew schools (where all instruction is given in the Hebrew language, the spiritual flag and symbol of the new national existence) are run on modern and Continental lines. The political life—though, of course, all in miniature—is already intense, and already one can observe in embryo the skeleton of the European body politic, with its groups of parties ranging from the extreme Clerical Right to the extreme Socialist Left.

Taking up the question of Sir Herbert Samuel’s job in Palestine, the writer finds that “Sir Herbert has been left a ticklish and delicate task by his predecessors in the Administration” for. .

it is a matter of notoriety that the late military Administration was, speaking generally, not only unsympathetic, but was specifically hostile to the Zionist policy of the British Foreign Office. There is definite reason to believe that it had its own military policy of a big dummy, nominally independent Arab Empire (which was to comprise Palestine), subsidized by British finance, exploited by British capital, administered by British officials (no doubt camouflaged as advisers), and intended in due course to fall into the political and economic pocket of Great Britain, and, under the Grand Viziership of a second Cromer (whose identity, indeed, it was not difficult to anticipate), to become a second Egypt with a similar series of complications.

It is certainly unquestionable that, during the last two years of British administration in Palestine, the wind of official policy blew steadily and surely in favor of the Arabs and against the Jews. The general attitude was that it was extremely doubtful whether the Balfour Declaration would ever be carried into the sphere of practical reality. Even the question of a British mandate was ostensibly regarded as uncertain, and it became fashionable to adopt in certain exalted quarters what has been cynically described as a “policy of simulated coyness with regard to the mandate.”

The writer finds that the fact of Sir Herbert being a Jew and a Zionist will have the very definite and salutary political effect of impressing upon the Arab population once and for all that the Foreign Office means real Zionist business, while the prudent and tactful administration which one can anticipate, without flattery or impertinence, should rapidly disperse the false and alarmist rumors as to the alleged sinister aims of the Zionist that have been spread among the population by those methods of intrigue and propaganda which the Arabs have reduced to so fine an art.

It is possible that at the beginning there may be a certain amount of friction, but a judicious readjustment of the administrative personnel, and in particular a purging of the administration of those native officials or servants who are known to have been implicated in anti-Zionist and anti-British intrigue, should go a long way towards bringing about a more healthy state of affairs than has existed during the last two years.

The writer is also confident of Sir Herbert's success.

There is, consequently, every reason to anticipate that the Administration of Sir Herbert Samuel, characterized, as it will doubtless be, by a combination of the maximum of firmness and the maximum of tact, and by a judicious balancing of the scales between the two parallel nationalities, will mark not only a new but an auspicious era in the history of Palestine.

November. 1920