Die Welt · Vol. IV, No. 13 · 30 March 1900
5printed page
scan 5 of 16
Facsimile · scan 5 of 16
Scan of p. 5
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 13. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.

There are, and there have always been, people who stand wholly without comprehension before such conduct, who cannot grasp that a man may emancipate himself so far from the "rational instinct of self-preservation" as to enter upon an unequal struggle in the certain knowledge that he must go under. These people, who have Heine's phrase about "heroic honour and foolery" for ever on their lips, are certainly quite right — but only if one contemplates the universe from the little standpoint of one's own "I," if one takes the sober view of the everyday, the policy of reckoning from to-day to to-morrow, for the summit of wisdom. And neither men of great feeling nor peoples with a sense of cultural mission have ever thought so; willingly have they sacrificed goods and blood to the command of honour, willingly, when the hour demanded it, have they staked their personality and their national existence, and, even against an overwhelmingly superior foe, delivered themselves up to destruction. For the secret of "national honour," which is supposed to be so hard to fathom, is in truth no mere phrase at all: it is the impulse to be allowed to preserve a pure self-respect before oneself and before others, to be allowed to live in that beauty for which not only the artist's heart yearns, but the heart of every nobly feeling man — the impulse to perish in beauty rather than to lead a merely tolerated existence, rotting away in the morass of the everyday.

The eyes of Europe are turned upon the struggle which, down yonder at the Cape, the little handful of Boers is waging against the world-power of England. We have little reason to be enthusiastic for the Boers, and still less occasion to hate England. For the Boers are a people culturally quite backward, which oppressed the native population with the extremest harshness, set a fanatical bigotry of faith against every non-Calvinist, and has treated our Jewish brethren in particular with the utmost intolerance. Everywhere, on the other hand, where the Union Jack floats, there is room for men of all nations and all zones, there rules the culture of a great and free people, there even the Jew is held to be a human being. If we reflect soberly, we have every reason to mourn over English defeats and to wish them a speedy and decisive victory, from which, despite the capture of Bloemfontein, they are still very far removed.

And yet, when we make all these reflections, when we arrive at the incontestable conclusion that we must rejoice in English victories, why in reality is it not so? Why does our interest nevertheless stand on the side of those who do not love us?

Because the little handful of men who are waging that war, the people which in numbers is no stronger than the English army at the Cape, has willingly taken up that great struggle for its threatened national honour, a struggle in which it would rather be beaten, rather perish, than surrender its own character. The beauty of such action lays hold of us, and we forget all shrewd calculations and considerations at the sight of the great spectacle of a whole people which, with the certainty of death in its heart, seeks a chivalrous end.

Perhaps the tragedy of this event lays hold of us Western European Zionists more than it would if we were merely objective and uninterested spectators. Perhaps we involuntarily refer a part of those events to ourselves, and feel in those battles a justification of our own conduct, which so vexes the Philistines about us, the exceedingly practical people on the Exchange and on the Jew-liberal papers. We have so often heard that we are fools and visionaries, who would do better to provide for the moment in our step-motherland, that we began to mistrust our very selves. Now we see the same people who scolded us for fools cheering on the Boers, and we begin to hold the logic of our opponents to be very weak. How, after all, did we become Zionists — we who find no unqualified sufficiency in the pious faith of our fathers, who are not pressed down by the material want of life, and who are not, like our brethren in the East, wholly hindered in our civic endeavour? Certainly we too suffer under slights; certainly we desired in social endeavour to contribute to the solution of the Jewish distress, which can be removed only by the way of Zionism. Certainly we have suffered with our brethren in their woe. But all this did not lay hold of our whole personality, so that we devoted ourselves, our very lives, to the idea. More than all this, we were driven into the struggle by the circumstance that men assailed the honour of our personality, that they grudged us the dignity of life, that they would degrade us into creatures glad when meat and drink are to their liking, creatures who may on no account presume to subsist as full and equal existences. It was not because honours and positions were refused us, not because the most incapable boors about us climbed over our heads, that we complained. That we leave in truth to those who are, alas, so practical. We became Zionists because we were suffocating in the atmosphere about us, because our best deeds, our best intentions, were paralysed merely because it was the dishonoured Jew who defended them. No cause was so good but that we discredited it, no undertaking so pure but that we drew down upon it the most venomous attacks, merely because it was we who wished to serve it. Honourable men cannot live so. We were of a finer organisation than the mass; therefore the desire of self-liberation came first to us. But the more coarsely organised will come too, to fight in our ranks — unless indeed our brethren have deserved the attacks directed against them.

And the poor peasant people in South Africa brings home to us that we have acted rightly.

Whoever continues to smile at us or to pity us, him we shall not further instruct. There is no purpose in disputing over conceptions which are not adequate to the understanding of the other party. We shall joyfully bring our idea every sacrifice it demands, and shall know withal that we have led a richer life than the censurers and the pitiers who would so wisely instruct us.

We need ground beneath our feet, spiritually and materially, and for these foundations of our idea we shall fight. We believe in victory, and this hope gives us double strength; but we should fight even then, were we forced to renounce hope, like those Boers who have shown us how a people ends — vanquished, and yet attended by the sympathies of all.

Should we go under in this struggle — well, at least the respect of our enemies will not be wanting to us. We desire to live, to rejoice in the sun like every other creature, but to live in honour. Otherwise — how does Ibsen's Hedda Gabler put it? "One must also die beautifully."