Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 21 · 22 May 1903
4printed page
scan 4 of 20

Page 4. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 21.

(continued from page 3)

…bad coat or a good man who is anxious for the poor of his people." As Lord Rothschild is able to afford a good tailor, I was compelled to conclude that I saw before me a good man in unselfish agitation. His anxiety not to shut the door upon the persecuted fugitives contrasts pleasantly with the Little Englandism of men like Alderman Harris. At the Alien Commission, which His Lordship attends so diligently, he has also had the opportunity of meeting our great leader, Dr. Herzl, face to face, and I do not believe that two men who so love their people could meet without good seed being sown. We need only understand one another in order now to work together.

Good Men, Bad Politicians.

When I last spoke in this hall I sharply criticised the Trustees of the Hirsch Foundation, and I do not propose to spare them to-day; but I have never seen in them anything other than patriotic, stiff-necked Israelites walking in darkness and without a guiding policy. It is one of the unhappy consequences of our having no Jewish political life, with a healthy mutual criticism, that we regard the denial of the success of a man's attentions as the denial of his goodness altogether. "He is such a good man," people object. We have been so accustomed to being led by good men that we have forgotten to ask whether the affairs of a people can be conducted without statesmen, and whether the circumstance that for so many centuries we have had only good men and learned rabbis at our head was not perhaps also partly to blame for the terrible streams of tears and blood that our people has shed. It has been said that wise men spend their time in correcting the errors of good men. Last year in this hall a friend of ours who is usually both good and wise, Dr. Gaster, blamed me for criticising the Trustees of the Hirsch Foundation. They were such good men! They had merely carried out the provisions of their statute! How does the matter stand to-day? Only a single Jewish paper in England and America, I might almost say in the world, finds a good word for the "Ica" Mr. Elkan Adler, at the Anglo-Jewish Association, called the history of the Ica one long muddle from beginning to end! Even Dr. Gaster is not here to defend them. The whole world is beginning to ask what has become of the money. Last year I stood almost alone; to-day even the "Ica" stands at my side, for it has gone to the House of Lords and said: "Forgive us our sins and permit us to commit them again in future!" This Bill is the crowning proof of the muddle. Not content with my assurance that they were acting illegally, they had to undergo a sort of mock trial before Sir Edward Fry, only that, unlike those mock trials at which people amuse themselves, the bill of costs was real. The judge's decision was the same that I had given them gratis. The "Ica," he said with profound juridical wisdom, was an association for Jewish colonisation. The Trustees could use their money only directly for founding colonies abroad; they could not do so indirectly for schools, factories, etc., in the lands of oppression. Whereupon the "Ica" made haste to petition Parliament, on the ground that great difficulties arise in applying its whole income strictly according to the statutes, and it begs leave to spend its millions not only on institutions which in-

directly promote immigration, but — and here one perceives the cloven hoof — in whatever direction.

The New Plans of the "Ica."

But to permit the Trustees to escape the irksome duty of colonisation means inevitably to destroy Baron Hirsch's great plan. I therefore strove most zealously, according to my small powers, to direct public attention to this danger, when the Bill quickly vanished and a second edition appeared, revised and corrected by Mr. Lousada. The demand to use their money otherwise has apparently been dropped, and the reason they have offered Parliament for the necessity of such an application is entirely changed. There is no longer any talk of their being unable to spend their money as Baron Hirsch directed, but rather that it would be of importance that the classes from which emigrants and colonists are recruited should receive some preliminary instruction.

I do not know which of these reasons is true. I know only that Mr. Lousada is a lawyer, and that this second reason is one of the cleverest expressions I have ever heard for veiling the truth. It is so clever that it even won favour. It is equalled only by that passage in the Bill itself which pretends that the institutions to be assisted are intended "to fit Jews for emigration." The way out is simple. Baron Hirsch intended to remove the Jews from the lands of oppression. His Trustees think that they should be left and educated in the lands of oppression — evidently only in order to feel their sufferings the better. The Trustees believe that education and other measures could bring about an improvement of conditions at home and remove the necessity of emigration. But instead of saying straight out "not emigration, but relief" — emigration is a failure, let us try improvement of conditions, which would at least suggest a reasonable view — they pretend that these two opposing tactical plans are one and the same; that the education is intended not for the improvement of present conditions, but for "the purposes of emigration." And so Mr. Lousada cleverly mixes in his phrases about the education of the classes from which emigrants and colonists are recruited. But which are these classes? They are the masses: ergo, you may have schools for the people at large; you may, for instance, furnish Roumania with a complete Jewish school system; and should some of the pupils emigrate, have you not prepared them for emigration? A more transparent sophistry was never foisted upon an unsuspecting Parliament. Major Evans Gordon, who in his anxiety to fulfil his duty faithfully on the Alien Commission has, unlike the Hirsch Trustees, taken pains to see with his own eyes, told me that, generally speaking, those who were trained for any calling by the "Ica" do not emigrate, and the people who emigrate were not trained by the "Ica."

It would have been far more honest to say: emigration is a mistake; let us try relief and improvement of present conditions.

Education through Loan Banks.

Had the "Ica" really meant that education leads to emigration, it would simply have applied for permission to found technical schools and model farms, and the Jewish colonies abroad would have been by