Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 40.
(continued from page 5)
…tas and put on too many airs. The fellowship of a great sorrow has not cemented Jewry together deeply enough, inwardly and lastingly enough.
And now, at the turn of the year, heavily charged clouds of new storms hang over our heads. We must therefore render ourselves an account of what we have not yet done and of what we must do.
Self-defence ought properly to form one part of the relief work. Let it be said openly: a proper self-defence — whether it should be established, how it should be directed, when it should be carried out or stopped — these are questions which only a general organization of the people would be called upon to decide. A general organization of the people! One shrinks from this word; one trembles in every limb on hearing anything like it. There lies the rub. This fear is a diasporic-pathological phenomenon — for in fact this clarity would do us no harm with the noble, and with the base we are branded once and for all. We could very well set forth the nature of our nationhood so clearly that no misgivings whatever could arise as regards civic duties and the like. It would perhaps have met with mild judgment, perhaps even with praise. And in fact we live in an age when people do not moralize at all, but the relations of power among the given factors decide.
The Jews did not formerly attempt to resort to self-defence. And yet it would be natural. "When the oppressed can nowhere find justice" — then nowadays he no longer reaches up into heaven to fetch down from there his eternal rights, but without more ado reaches for the revolver, etc., to make the oppressors feel that to the weak, too, a sting is given. And yet the Jews never did so — until the very latest time. When one casts one's glance backward up the ages, when one sees how the Russian tchin of the old stamp ruled and raged in the Jewish Pale of Settlement, where after all the Jews were there before the Russians; when one considers how the stage-managed Jew-baiters already in the eighties utterly destroyed whole communities, how they annihilated tens of thousands of Jewish men, women, old people and children by means of hunger and misery — by way of legislation! — or forced them to flee from house and home and native place; when one beholds the mass of outrages and atrocities which brutal insolence has perpetrated through generations — then, indeed, one will wonder that the maltreated, the robbed, the outlawed and the expelled did not long since try to shake their fetters in fury and turn out their sting.
They did not try it, because there was no purely Jewish self-defence, because the people was enslaved and humbled. Only when political passions poured so hotly and mightily over the Empire of the Tsars, and when a part of the Jewish youth, swept along by the general current and influenced by general moods, looked upon the destinies of its own people — did the idea of a self-defence develop. It is a mixtum compositum, like the relief work. It has fine, uplifting moments, as that has; it lacks true national solidarity, as that does. The relief work turns natural nationhood into a humanitarian-political pap — the self-defence does not follow the straight national line, but vibrates by fits and starts between the general and the specific.
People will shrug their shoulders over this "childishness". They will perhaps also condemn the "fault-finding". The practical men of reality will ask: Well, what then is one actually to do? The answer is short: one must be a people! Only imagine the strength of the Jews if they really regarded themselves as a people. At whatever part the body of the people were attacked, in a trice the pain would thrill through the whole body, from head to foot. The demarcations vanish, the barriers are broken down, and when the Jews in Odessa tremble in mortal danger, their brethren in Budapest tremble too on their account; and when an expelled Jew comes over, he is not the wanderer but the equal in a people that, now here and now there, in different epochs and under different conditions of life, is subject to one and the same destiny. Here, in this consciousness, lies the centre of gravity of the difference of system which separates us from all the half-measures — however sympathetic they may be in themselves as momentary beneficent episodes.
The past year has brought us — perhaps, alas, at the cost of too great sacrifices — a hair's breadth nearer to the victory of this principle, but we are still far from being able to put this principle into practice. For the present we must content ourselves with philanthropy. We have first to gather ourselves, to deepen and to strengthen ourselves, before our time will come, the time of a Jewish general organization that is a matter of course. And let this apply not especially to the West; let it apply also to the centres of the masses, and perhaps with greater justification. We can very well conceive of a Jewish organization — naturally in association with smaller organizations. It is a fact that there is hardly a single man in the Jewish people who does not belong to a freely chosen association, that is to say to an organization, leaving aside the individual stunted and ossified communities. There exists a whole army of smaller and larger societies; only no attempt has ever yet been made to mobilize them and to use them for the purpose of a larger action. First there would come the trade guilds: the tailors, the shoemakers, the bakers, the smiths, etc., which in fact, wherever they are present in considerable numbers, form certain corporate bodies. Then the countless charitable societies, which in fact mean something other than the current notion of charity, since with Jews it is more a matter of personal service; thus in the first place the "Linos Hozedek", "Bikur Cholim", "Ezras Jessomim", "Gmilus Ch'sodim", "Hachnosas Orchim", etc. And then the newer associations: fire-brigade societies, workers' organizations, etc. In all these societies and little societies, which are to be found in the smallest townlets, the people is contained. And though one should cherish no illusions about the tautness of the organization that prevails there, these existing organizations, which have maintained themselves so long among the people, can at least be the signposts showing how one to the great
