No. 40. — "Die Welt" — Page 7.
(continued from page 6)
…and the whole can attain. And it might well be possible to move these societies each to elect one member from their midst, so that these in their turn should send a delegate to a great, general assembly of the Jews from every corner and end of our ghetto: a power which, well led, might be of incalculable effect.
But courage and initiative are lacking. Ghetto Jewry, too, is caught in a peculiar assimilation: the boldest mixtures of every theory, the most daring combinations, the most dreadful nervousness, the most hair-splitting brooding, and a differentiation that makes not only the people fall apart into individuals, but the individuals themselves fall apart within into small pieces. And here, too, there are fine moments and strokes of genius to be observed, but no single governing idea and no healthy will of the people. The countless parties, the multiplying doctrines, grow out of decay, out of decline, out of the wearied and enfeebled genius of the people. It is not a forward striving that represents a fruit of ripeness, of fulfilment in what has gone before, but a forward rushing that very often springs from unripeness. The parties shoot up out of the earth like mushrooms, and instead of forming a closed phalanx we split ourselves up more and more, and much strength is squandered for nothing.
A year full of gravity and care, full of good works, but of far greater neglects and omissions, has passed over us.
N. Sokolow.
POLITICAL REVIEW
Legal Recognition of the Jewish Nationality
The question of the recognition of the Jewish nationality, as the "Information" reports from Vienna, is at present before a central authority of the Austrian Government for a decision in principle. An Austrian subject of the Jewish confession, at an official recording of his personal particulars, demanded that "Jewish" be officially entered under the heading "Nationality"; this the authority of first instance refused, pointing out that the designation "Jewish" could be expressed only under the heading of confession. The complainant, who appealed as far as the Ministry, held to his contention that there is a Jewish nationality, whose recognition in principle he demanded. The Ministry of the Interior did not dismiss the claimant out of hand, but obtained an opinion from the University of Vienna and from the Government's officials for religious affairs, who, though not in so definite a manner as the lower authority, expressed the view that the recognition of a separate Jewish nationality did not, in their opinion, appear opportune on account of its consequences. The complainant now intends to go to the highest and final instance, the Administrative Court.
So far the report.
It is scarcely to be supposed that the Administrative Court will content itself with examining the question purely as to whether administrative or political difficulties may arise from establishing the existence of the Jewish nationality. In all probability the complainant is a Galician Jew, who could in good conscience give Yiddish as his mother tongue. In that case the Administrative Court will have no choice — by analogy with earlier decisions concerning other small races of Austria — but to establish the existence of a Jewish community whose bounds do not coincide with the confessional Jewish community hitherto provided for in law. And since in Austria above all the principle of territorial compactness has long ceased to count as decisive, as a fundamental condition for recognising the concept of nationality, every reason falls away for not recognising as a nationality the Jewish community distinguished by its mother tongue. Once the Jewish nationality has been recognised as actually and rightfully existing for the Yiddish-speaking Jews, it is then left — likewise by analogy with the provisions in force for the other Austrian nationalities — to every Jew whose mother tongue is a language other than Yiddish to profess the Jewish nationality or not. Fundamental changes will of course result from this in all the legal provisions concerning the Jews, in that the religious (ecclesiastical) affairs of members of the Jewish confession will have to be clearly set apart, in particular, from the political and public-law affairs of members of the Jewish nationality. In this respect, given the peculiar position of the Jewish confession in law, the analogy of the other nations can be drawn upon only in part. But that the juridical form for the division into two — into a religious and a national community — will be found, if perhaps with somewhat greater difficulties than for other nationalities, is self-evident.
The matter is in any case of the greatest interest in principle and in politics, and deserves in high degree the attention of the Austrian national Jews. The time is ripe for the legal establishment of a principle which de facto already asserts itself so strongly and energetically in public life, and has also won such wide acceptance among the non-Jewish peoples of Austria.
We, however, may see from this how natural development strides forward piece by piece — towards our goal.
Jewish Learning
An interesting controversy concerning "Jewish learning at the German universities" has taken place between the Koenigsberg scholar Dr. Perles and the well-known Protestant Orientalist Prof. König. Whereas Dr. Perles complained of the neglect and slighting of the "Science of Judaism," Prof. König asserted that Old Testament research, and Hebrew philology generally, are most zealously cultivated. Prof. König is a well-known specialist in the field of Biblical research — and it is therefore not to be wondered at that he took Dr. Perles' complaints as a kind of personal matter, all the more so since Prof. König is among the readers of the honourable "Kreuzzeitung" and those who share its views. It is true, indeed, that the so-called "Science of Judaism" is cultivated at the German universities. But only do not ask how. Biblical research, Old Testament philology, exegesis — with these the circle of the Jewish sciences is closed. If by "Science of Judaism" only theology is understood, then it would of course be natural for it to be taught by qualified Jewish specialists. But that is not the case. The most important disciplines of Jewish theology are expounded, with a bias, by Christian, Protestant scholars. In Germany we are still
2
